Google Squared is a new Google Labs application for displaying search data in a more organized fashion than those regular ol’ search results. For music collectors, this tool has the potential of being very useful for discovering musical genres.
Let’s say, for example, that you want to add more Rock to your collection. A Google Squared search results for “Rock Music Genres” returns with many suggestions in a very organized view.
Having this detailed view saves you some time in cherry-picking through search results. In a well-organized view you get to see all Rock sub-genres. You’ll be able to tell from this view which genres you are missing from your music collection.
These first few versions of the application will simply offer the ability to traverse the genre tree. In a few months, I will add the ability to get information on each genre and possibly add a community around the site.
One of the reasons I am offering an advanced sneak-peek is to get feedback regarding the overall look-and-feel and to get suggestions on the genre tree itself.
soundunwound is a new Amazon.com music site that has been curated with information from Amazon’s own music database, imdb, and musicbrainz. This is a great site to find all the information you need on a certain musical artist. Soundwound is artist-focused, not enough emphasis is placed on genres.
Genres appear on each artist’s page to describe them. This site breaks down the genres in three levels (mainly, quite, hints of), as you will see in the following screenshot for Calexico.
clicking on a genre takes you to a description and top artists on that genre. These are a few criticisms that I have come up with after playing around for a while:
there is not one page where we can take a look at all the genres together in an organized fashion. It seems that the only way to get to a genre page is to search for an artist, then click on a genre describing that genre.
many of the genres seem to have no descriptions. Really ? how much would it have cost Amazon to pay somebody to simply copy-n-paste from wikipedia ? It seems that the information for the populated genres has been retrieved from wikipedia – so why not complete them all, or most of ‘em ?
For finding artist information this site has potential – maybe even calling it the imdb for music. However as a site for finding information about genres and discovering music based on genres it lacks some points.
Over at Out Digital Music blog, they have started a series of blog entries to define the most commonly used terms revolving around digital music. Yesterday’s term was “AAC” and today’s term was “Bitrate“, for example. I highly recommend to anybody starting to collect digital music to follow this blog to get acquainted with the Digital Music lexicon.
Over at techno.org, you can find a well-constructed Electronic music genre tree. The authors claim to “entertain before it informs”, which is how we should really treat any music genre tree. As I have mentioned in the past, music genres are one of the most subjective topics, therefore all music genre trees should be taken with a grain of salt. The tutorial found in this site is a good explanation on electronic music, in general. Have fun there.
While researching several sources for building up the initial phases of the music genre tree, I have found several good sources that I plan to reference. These are a few of the most interesting sites in no particular order:
Rate Your Music: A Social network revolving around music. I haven’t tried their core site, but their genre tree is public and quite good.
Wikipedia’s Geneology of Cuban Music: Shows a subset of the complete music genre tree. It is just interesting to see how you can represent genres while taking in consideration region and period of time.
A Taxonomy of Music Genres: A research paper presented at Content-Based Multimedia Information Access Conference in April 2000. A great, and educational, read for anybody interested in music genres.
One of the sites on my rss feed is http://aurgasm.us/. Each week, or so, they feature a new artist and a few mp3s by that artist. Recently, they featured a great female vocalist: Melody Gardot. Finding out about her made following this website worthwhile. I just listened to her two songs offered by this post: Goodnite and Worrisome Heart. Now, I must get all her songs.
About a year ago I posted my idea regarding a standard music genre tree. Since then, I’ve been sketching out my ideas regarding such a tree. Bascially, my idea is a web application that will allow users to contribute in creating the most complete music genre tree available. I am debating whether to allow artists or songs to be assigned to these genres – but classifying artists and/or songs is a very dauting task, therefore, this might have to wait. The most important thing is that I started writing this new web application and will be available very soon. It even has a domain of its own, now: http://www.musicgenretree.com